
Somewhere between the office cookie swap and the email marked FINAL final really final, somebody at a nonprofit has to decide how much peanut butter to order for January. If I were writing that organization’s year end appeal, I’d pull up a chair next to whoever does the ordering. I bet they have a better opening line than “As another year draws to a close.”
I’d ask what they wish they could count on every month. Maybe the answer is as ordinary as knowing they can place the Friday food order. There’s your story. A donor can picture a shelf, a shopping list and a person making a decision. Try picturing “the sustainability of our ongoing initiatives.” I’ll wait.
Monthly giving deserves that kind of specificity. In the 2026 M+R Benchmarks study, monthly gifts accounted for 27% of participating nonprofits’ online revenue in 2025. Here’s how I’d invite a December donor to become a monthly one, using a food program as an example.
Thank you for helping us stock the shelves in December. We’re putting together the January food orders now. A monthly gift gives us a better idea of what we can order for the families who count on us. Would you like to help with the groceries each month?
Call the button “Help with the monthly groceries.” Tap it on your phone. Can you see the amount, the word “monthly” and how to change your gift later? Hand the phone to someone who didn’t build the page. The spot where their thumb hovers is the spot I want to see.
More than 30 years in marketing have made me particular about the order of two things. A thank you comes first. The next invitation can wait. I use the donor database to find people who gave in December, send them news of what their gift helped do, then offer the monthly option. People who already give monthly get a different note. Imagine faithfully sending money every month and getting an email wondering if you’ve ever considered faithfully sending money every month.
If your board is staring at a blank year end appeal, write to me at info@thespotmarketing.com. Tell me one thing your program needs every month. Peanut butter is a perfectly respectable answer.